Not all smart devices are worth the investment. Some are nice-to-haves, while others can genuinely save you hundreds of dollars each year.

Here's a data-driven look at which smart devices offer the best return on investment, with real numbers on potential savings.

1. Smart Thermostat

$140-180
Average annual savings

Smart thermostats are the undisputed champions of smart home ROI. Here's why they save so much:

  • Learning algorithms adjust to your actual schedule
  • Geofencing turns off when everyone leaves
  • Remote control prevents heating/cooling an empty house
  • Energy reports help you optimize further

Return on Investment

Average cost: $200-250
Payback period: 12-18 months
5-year savings: $700-900

Top picks: Ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium, Google Nest Learning Thermostat, Honeywell Home T9

2. Smart Power Strips

$100-200
Average annual savings

"Vampire power" or "phantom load" is the electricity devices use when they're off but still plugged in. It accounts for 5-10% of residential electricity use.

Smart power strips eliminate this waste by:

  • Cutting power completely to devices when not in use
  • Scheduling entertainment centers to power off at night
  • Using motion or timer-based automation

Return on Investment

Average cost: $25-50 each
Payback period: 3-6 months

3. Smart Water Leak Sensors

$10,000+
Potential damage prevented

Water damage is one of the most common and expensive home insurance claims. A single undetected leak can cause:

  • Structural damage
  • Mold growth (expensive remediation)
  • Ruined flooring and drywall
  • Damaged personal belongings
Insurance discount: Many insurers offer 5-10% premium discounts for homes with water leak detection systems. This alone can pay for the sensors within a year.

Place sensors near:

  • Water heater
  • Washing machine
  • Under sinks
  • Near toilets
  • Sump pump area

Return on Investment

Cost for 5-pack: $100-150
Insurance savings: $50-150/year

4. Smart Sprinkler Controller

$200-400
Average annual savings on water

If you have an irrigation system, a smart controller can dramatically reduce water waste:

  • Weather-based scheduling skips watering before rain
  • Zone-specific timing based on plant types and sun exposure
  • Seasonal adjustments automatically reduce watering in fall/spring
  • Leak detection alerts you to broken sprinkler heads

Return on Investment

Average cost: $150-250
Payback period: 6-12 months

Top picks: Rachio 3, RainMachine, Orbit B-hyve

5. Smart LED Bulbs

$50-100
Annual savings (for typical home)

While LEDs themselves save money, smart LEDs add additional savings through:

  • Scheduling lights to turn off automatically
  • Motion-activated lighting (only on when needed)
  • Dimming capabilities (dimmed lights use less energy)
  • Vacation mode (random lighting patterns while away)
Note: The savings from smart bulbs alone are modest. Their value increases when combined with other smart devices and automations.

6. Smart Water Heater Controller

$100-150
Average annual savings

Water heating accounts for about 18% of your energy bill. Smart controllers optimize this by:

  • Heating water only when you need it
  • Learning your hot water usage patterns
  • Lowering temperature during vacations
  • Alerting you to potential issues

Devices That Don't Save Money (But Are Still Useful)

These smart devices won't reduce your bills, but offer convenience or security:

Smart Locks

Great for convenience and security, but no direct savings

Smart Speakers

Control hub for other devices, but don't save money themselves

Video Doorbells

Security benefits, but monthly subscription costs add up

Robot Vacuums

Time saver, but electricity use offsets any potential savings

Total Potential Annual Savings

Smart Thermostat $140-180
Smart Power Strips (3) $100-200
Insurance Discount (leak sensors) $50-150
Smart Sprinkler Controller $200-400
Smart Lighting $50-100
Total Annual Savings $540-1,030

Track Your Smart Home ROI with NestorAI

NestorAI helps you monitor the performance and savings from your smart devices:

  • Log purchase dates, costs, and warranty information
  • Track utility bills to measure actual savings
  • Get reminders for firmware updates and maintenance
  • Calculate your total smart home investment and returns
Get Started Free